Choose Chicago – But What Brand Do We Want Them To Choose?

Here, go craft a brand that speaks for an entire city.

It’s a gigantic challenge for the Choose Chicago team that CEO of Johnson Publishing Desiree Rogers heads. Chicago needs a fresh tourism campaign that captures the imagination of potential travelers abroad who can spend a pretty penny on their destination of choice. Why? There’s a new set of questions. There’s crime. There’s teacher layoffs. There’s a pension crisis. There’s an inordinate amount of debate over Wrigley Field Jumbotrons. And we’re still feeling a bit of a sting over not getting the Olympics and what that means in terms of how the world views our city.

2013-07-13 11.46.25

A view from the quieter, more family-friendly Ohio Street Beach. Just one of the many pleasant surprises you can find in Chicago that you don’t have to look too hard for.

Well, let’s start by not relying on tired old cliches to describe ourselves if we want to brand differently. Yet, in a recent interview with Chicago Magazine, Rogers described some ads that frankly, sound like the kind of tourism ad messages that anybody could come up with in their sleep.

Chicago Magazine: What are the U.K. ads like?
Desiree Rogers: Tongue in cheek. From “Over the pond, we have a lake” to “You have Big Ben, we have a big Bean” to “Put down your shepherd’s pie,” with an image of a deep-dish pizza. It’s on double-decker buses, taxicabs, even the receipts in the taxis.

That’s a little too cutesie. The kind of expected stuff that everybody thinks about. Yes, we have a lake. And pizza. And hot dogs. And the Cubs. And the immortal Frank Sinatra singing about us. But please, let’s stop going to that well. We just can’t keep going there if we’re going to change perceptions. People know all that about our city without coming here – right down to the tagline of “Chicago: Second To None.” We get it. We’re the Second City. Never heard that one before.

Can we get real here and step into the minds of potential tourists?

You don’t invest thousands of dollars on an overseas trip to Chicago because you want to compare bodies of water and try some pizza – even if the pie is fabulous. That’s Cliche Chicago. Not why you Choose Chicago.

If we dig deeper, we know that Chicago is so much more. We have to raise the profile of the hidden gems that make our city so worth discovering.

Let’s take music. If I see one more reference to the Blues Brothers, I’m going to puke. We know the movie. It was also done about 35 years ago (ignoring anything attempted by Jim Belushi to channel his brother). We’ve got a lot more going for us in the present day we can talk about.

People want great quality blues and jazz? They can have a fabulous experience at Buddy Guy’s Legends. The Green Mill. Kingston Mines. They know the Chicago Symphony Orchestra’s world-class reputation, but have they taken in the experience of listening to live classical music (CSO or Grant Park Symphony Orchestra) under the stars in Millennium Park?

Or let’s take restaurants. Look, I love a cheezeborger, cheezeborger from Billy Goat Tavern as much as anyone. Ditto the pizza from Gino’s. But let’s throw a little more into the mix. A lot more. We’ve got hundreds of options populating every possible ethnicity known to mankind. Let’s showcase those too. I’m not imagining the fact that there are 300 options or so highlighted every month in Chicago Magazine. It’s a foodie’s paradise.

My thought? Take everything that the average person would know or guess about Chicago without coming here and wipe it right off the table as an option. Yes, they know Oprah and Michael and Da Coach hung their hats here. That’s over and done. They know about Al Capone – that’s really, really over and done. And don’t get me started on the tourist trap also known as Navy Pier.

This town’s charm – for someone who has spent the majority of his life in it – is that there is always a new restaurant, new bar, new concert experience, new shopping destination, new sporting event, new architectural marvel to tour, new museum exhibit to absorb and more.

Chicago is an ever changing-experience. It is never boring. And so much of it is wonderfully accessible without overwhelming its guests in a bad way. It is the easiest big city to customize your experience around with a myriad of options and still not feel as though you left so much more on the table unfulfilled.

From those experiences, you tell your friends upon your return of the things you never thought you’d partake in in Chicago. It whets their appetite to learn more. And they do.

In so many ways, our brand can be a best kept secret and some would say almost too secret for their tastes. But if we’re going to raise the profile and convert event opportunities from a short list of bids to a victorious outcome, we have to share the stories of our city that nobody could hope to read in a standard Wikipedia entry about Chicago. There’s thousands of those stories being told by visitors who are single, married, have kids, retired and more.

That’s why traditional advertising isn’t the best way to share that story unless it drives the reader to a place where they can read more online. We need lots and lots and lots of positive Chicago experiences shared. I’m very skeptical you can get there in a 3-5 ad campaign series. You can get there in a series of social media posts, however. So if we’re going to plaster London and other European cities with our advertising, let’s make sure it’s only the beginning of the conversation, not cute throwaway headlines that go nowhere.

For example, can we follow each day of an English couple’s first stay in Chicago? Can we follow them to their romantic stops? See their pictures and videos? Learn more about why they chose to come Chicago and to ramp up the interactivity, even recommend places for them via social media in the moment while they’re here? And when they return home, can we encourage these travelers to be tour guides for future travelers considering Chicago?

There is massive opportunity to share multiple stories simultaneously via Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Pinterest, Instagram, Google Plus and more – and in fairness, Choose Chicago is doing a solid job of that storytelling online, particularly on Facebook. The concern I have is that I wonder what’s taking the lead in telling the story media-wise (traditional or social) and message-wise (here’s an idea – let’s use images of real people who are actually still alive and, if we’re going to use real residents, let’s choose ones that live here throughout the year rather than celebrities who call it home among their multiple other homes. Deal?).

It’s time to step away from the comfort zone of what everybody assumes about Chicago and share the unexpected, unplanned and remarkably surprising it can and does so often give.

After all, that’s what the best vacations are made of.

6 thoughts on “Choose Chicago – But What Brand Do We Want Them To Choose?

  1. Another great post that hits the nail on the head, Dan! The whole time I was reading this I couldn’t help but nod along in agreement. One of my favorite lines was, “And don’t get me started on the tourist trap also known as Navy Pier.” I chuckle when family & friends come to visit for the first and that’s one of their top places to go. Funny thing, the next time they come to visit they don’t have to go back there. Hmmm….

    One of the best things about Chicago is that there are so many different layers to it and by focusing only on the past, people are missing out on what truly makes this such a fantastic city today!

    • Absolutely, Amy. Glad you enjoyed it. I think every big city has this one place that is prominently used in our tourism imagery and one of the last places a local would go. For us (or at least for this local), it’s the Pier. I have friends in San Francisco who describe Fisherman’s Wharf in the same way. And so on.

      We have to view our guests as not the endgame but as an audition – because what those travelers say about us to their friends, family and others in their social network circles will be hugely influential. We often have one shot to get it right in our message, particularly with overseas travelers. In that finite window of when they stay with us, it’s the things they happily stumble upon while here that are often more chatter-worthy. I truly believe this town offers those opportunities and plenty of them.

  2. So, Dan, you’re brief is: “Chicago is an ever changing-experience. It is never boring”? That’s, uh, distinctive. I agree the other stuff is cliched. But I don’t think you’ve given them a reason to choose Chicago over a dozen other destinations.

    • That’s quite the oversimplification of what I’ve stated. I didn’t merely say that “it’s never boring.” In fact, in one of the scenarios I’ve proposed, we follow the thread of different visitors through the city to a series of lesser-known-to-an-international-audience destinations in the city that are both chosen by them and suggested via a social media audience through Facebook, Twitter and other channels. This weaves a richer story of their journey and in turn, tells a more sophisticated tale about Chicago itself. In one series, it’s a single traveler. Another a retired couple. And so on. Rather than a traditional tourism campaign that may highlight just one spot of the city in one ad, we encourage the audience of both local Chicagoans and people who have traveled here before to not only follow the featured travelers but also participate and have a hand in recommending where they stop next on their vacation. In the process, we share dozens of destinations of Chicago rather than only a few and encourage greater 2-way interactivity than just telling it in a traditional 1-way manner. And the campaign is integrated between online and offline.

  3. Hi Dan,

    I just came across this post while researching the Chicago tourism brands. I don’t belong to a marketing agency or top corporation. I’m a regular Chicago born resident, who’s tired of my city embarrassing itself will lame marketing, and showing how out of touch it is with international tourism. I’ve created a branding proposal for the city to use. But, I’ve tried to submit it. But, I doubt the city looks at my plans with me not being apart of a company.

    • I don’t want to dissuade you from submitting it, but your best bet is to inquire with Choose Chicago since that seems to be the official party. In a perfect world, great ideas would find a way to get in the right hands. But of course, we’re talking about the government here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s